NY court invalidates Oneidas Turning Stone casino - Wednesday 12th of October 2005
A New York State Appellate Court has upheld a lower courts ruling invalidating the Oneida Indian tribes Turning Stone casino because the legislature did not approve it.
But the casino is still taking bets and it is not known whether any state or federal officials will shutter it.
"My take is neither one wants to do it," said Cornelius Murray, an anti-casino attorney with the Albany office of OConnell and Aronowitz who won the lawsuit and who has filed several suits that aim to block casinos.
Turning Stone is one of the areas top employers with 4,200 workers, and Murray said shutting it could be politically unpopular.
Located 30 miles east of Syracuse, the 12-year-old casino draws 4 million visitors a year, but does not share any of its revenues with the state.
Jerry Reed, an Oneida spokesman, said the tribe would appeal the latest legal setback. "The nations compact is a completely valid compact under federal law, and no federal court has ever said otherwise," Reed said.
New York states constitution bars casinos unless they are on Indian reservations.
The Oneidas and other tribes that for years fought to build casinos in the Catskills hit another roadblock this year. The U.S. Supreme Court said the Oneidas cannot recreate reservations by buying ancestral lands.
The court sided with Sherrill, N.Y., which wants to tax firms located on land the tribe bought in 1997 for its reservation.
The ruling makes it hard for tribes to create new reservations unless they can get the federal governments approval, Murray said. But getting that approval is a lengthy process, he added.
The Oneida spokesman declined comment on the Supreme Court case, noting other tax lawsuits are pending in several courts.
New Yorks appellate court followed a precedent set by the states top court. Two years ago, the Court of Appeals invalidated the St. Regis Mohawks casino because the legislature also did not approve that compact.
But lawmakers later approved a new accord with the tribe, which lets them keep their St. Lawrence County casino.
Spokesmen for Republican Gov. George Pataki, who is not seeking another term, and Democratic Attorney General Eliot Spitzer, who is running for governor, were not available.
In mid-September, Patakis counsel asked the National Indian Gaming Commission to "... immediately advise it whether the ongoing gaming activities at Turning Stone are authorized by federal law."
If Turning Stone is illegal, Platkin asked the federal agency to tell New York whether it "intends to take action and the nature of such action."
Other news from around the same time
Gas prices could hurt Las Vegas - Wednesday 12th of October 2005
This gambling mecca could lose millions of tourists if gasoline prices get stuck above $3 a gallon i....
Gulf Coast casinos get second chance - Wednesday 12th of October 2005
LOS ANGELES (Reuters) - Hurricane Katrinas destruction of the Mississippi Gulf Coast may lead to a b....
Pokies money missing - Wednesday 12th of October 2005
MANAGERS at two RSL pokies venues have allegedly stolen almost $200,000 to feed their gambling addic....
Gambling addict stole £10m to feed habit - Wednesday 12th of October 2005
A GAMBLING-mad former financial consultant stole £10 million to bankroll an unsuccessful obsession ....
Conned by the casino addict - Wednesday 12th of October 2005
A GAMBLER is facing prison after he conned victims out of a fortune to bankroll a huge betting spree....
Leading Poker Vendor Tribeca Tables Chooses Phantom Fibers Advanced Wireless Platform For Mobile Poker - Wednesday 12th of October 2005
Phantom Fiber Corporation (OTCBB:PHFB) the leading developer of wireless platform software announced....
Labour’s casinos gamble with people’s lives - Wednesday 12th of October 2005
One of the poorest communities in Britain is one step closer to getting a super casino thanks to New....
FAIRGROUND GAMING LISTS ON AIM - Wednesday 12th of October 2005
Fairground Gaming, the newly-established investment company in the online gaming sector, has today a....
EC casino licences soon up for grabs - Wednesday 12th of October 2005
THE Eastern Cape is expected to call for proposals for the provinces remaining two casino licences, ....
THE FUTURE OF GAMBLING: Innovation is served - Wednesday 12th of October 2005
Game change may be just a click away for casino slot operators. Server-based gaming will make it so.....