Judge lays cards on table, forbids poker - Thursday 12th of May 2005

The expert witnesses came from Las Vegas, the Bahamas and Florida to testify that poker is chiefly a game of skill. But Durham's senior judge wasn't willing to take the gamble. Poker is a game of chance, he ruled, that can get betting players locked up in North Carolina. Superior Court Judge Orlando Hudson's decision Monday stymied The Joker Club, which had hoped to open a poker-betting establishment here. A club lawyer indicated that Hudson's decision might be appealed. Hudson said later he is not a poker player himself, but has no moral or religious scruples about the game. He also said a state law against poker betting dates to the 19th century and might be antiquated.

"The culture is different now," he said. "Society is different. The law is ambiguous in a number of different ways." The law says it is illegal to bet on games in which chance "predominates" over skill, Hudson said. "[But] how do you measure that?" he asked rhetorically. "If the legislature told us what they had in mind, I'd understand. But they didn't tell us what it means." Still, Hudson said, he was bound to follow the law as it was written. The Joker Club leased a building on Ferrell Road in November, indicating it wished to open "a business that allows adult persons to play poker against one another and whereby [the club] will retain a portion of funds which are wagered by the players." In its effort to make that happen, the club sued former District Attorney Jim Hardin Jr. after he wrote that poker betting "does not comply with the law." Hardin said he would order police and sheriff's deputies to crack down on any perceived violations. After at least two postponements, the case belatedly found its way into court on Monday. Hardin, now a judge, was not there. Lawyer Marcus Hill, one of three attorneys representing The Joker Club, argued that 37 states have "some form of" legalized poker. "Of course, there is an element of luck in all games," Hill acknowledged.

"There is an element of luck in poker. But skill will prevail." Assistant Attorney General David J. Adinolfi II countered that "there are no cases whatsoever that state or imply that poker is anything but illegal" in North Carolina. "We're not talking about shuffleboard here," Adinolfi said. "We're not talking about archery. Poker is simply not legal. ... The turn of a card is what settles it all. The best player in the world can get beat by an amateur. Chance predominates. Chance overwhelms skill. "The cards are dealt face down. You can be as skilled as possible. You can do all the statistical analyses. But chance predominates when you flip the card over. It's just that simple. You can't will the card to be an ace when it's a deuce." Adinolfi also said the state Court of Appeals and state Supreme Court previously declared poker betting to be illegal in North Carolina. "This court doesn't pass legislation," Adinolfi said of Hudson. "This court can't overrule the Supreme Court and the Court of Appeals." In branding poker betting as illegal, the Legislature apparently wanted to protect low- and middle-income players "from getting beaten out of their paychecks every week," Adinolfi added. The Joker Club pulled some human aces from its sleeve during its unsuccessful court bid on Monday.

One of them was Roy Cooke of Las Vegas, a 16-year professional poker player and lead columnist for Card Player Magazine. He said the skills involved in poker include emotional fortitude, statistical expertise and the ability to "read" the minds and mannerisms of opponents. "Unskilled players tend to lose their money," Cooke said. "Luck is a neutral factor over the course of time. The person who says he is unlucky year in and year out really doesn't play well and is in denial." Anthony Lee, vice president of a casino in the Bahamas, also came to Durham to testify on Monday. He acknowledged that he is not a skilled poker player and, as a result, not a good one. "I can't bluff," Lee added. "In poker, you need certain skills which I haven't worked on." Frank Martin, a Florida poker consultant and tournament organizer, agreed in testimony that poker "is definitely" a game of skill. "Sure, there is an element of chance," he said. "But that's part of the beauty of it. You're using chance to your benefit by understanding what you're dealing with. The chance part of it can be overcome by the fact that you can induce people to fold."

www.heraldsun.com

Other news from around the same time

Camelot aims for third lottery licence after hitting jackpot - Thursday 12th of May 2005

THE public has rekindled its love affair with the National Lottery by spending an extra £150m a yea....


Mississippi firm hopes to build casino on Tyne - Thursday 12th of May 2005

ANOTHER US casino operator has unveiled plans for a hotel and leisure complex in the region.The Isle....


Gaming groups prepare to float as betting fever sweeps the UK - Thursday 12th of May 2005

Lord Steinberg, the founder of the casino operator Stanley Leisure, is in line to become chairman of....


Pauma tribe sues casino giants - Monday 23rd of January 2006

The Pauma Indian tribe has sued two multibillion-dollar casino giants, contending they conspired to ....


Gaming chief logs on - Thursday 12th of May 2005

One of the leading figures in the traditional gaming industry, Lord Leonard Steinberg, is to embrace....


Hilton bets on gaming recovery - Thursday 12th of May 2005

PROFITS at Hilton have dipped 4 per cent in the first four months of 2005 - but the hotels-to-bookma....


Camelot gets lucky with interactive lottery sales - Thursday 12th of May 2005

Camelot will this week claim that it has become the largest interactive lottery in the world, after ....


Harrah's Offers $750 Million in Notes - Thursday 12th of May 2005

Harrah's Operating Company, Inc., a wholly owned subsidiary of Harrah's Entertainment, Inc. (NYSE:HE....


United's chances of supercasino remote - Thursday 12th of May 2005

THE head of casinos at Stanley Leisure yesterday dismissed the chances of Manchester United securing....


Profits dip at Hilton - Thursday 12th of May 2005

Hotels and gaming company Hilton Group (LSE: HG.L - news - msgs) said profits for the first four mon....