McCain takes aim at off-reservation gambling - Sunday 12th of June 2005
Congress never intended for Indians to build Nevada-style casinos away from their reservations, and tribes risk a backlash by pursuing the trend, Sen. John McCain said Tuesday.
"None of us ever anticipated that there would be casinos in the Catskills," McCain, chairman of the Senate Indian Affairs Committee, told a tribal leader from New York who's pursuing such a project.
"We're seeing casinos in downtown Oakland and downtown Denver. ... If we have enough off-reservation casinos set up in America we're going to see a backlash against Indian gaming, because that was not the intent of the law," said McCain, R-Ariz.
The projects near Oakland and on the outskirts of Denver have not been approved, but several tribes have succeeded in establishing off-reservation casinos, and many more are pursuing them.
The trend has surfaced as Indian gambling has transformed in recent years from a relatively small industry into a huge one, generating an estimated $18.5 billion in 2004, nearly double the take from Nevada's gambling industry.
Not all tribes have benefited. Those with reservations near populated areas have been able to cash in, while those with remote reservations have often struggled. Some of those have sought to lay claim to better-situated land and build casinos there.
Under the 1988 Indian Gaming Regulatory Act, off-reservation gambling is allowed only under a narrow set of exceptions, but tribes are increasingly pursuing those options or finding other ways. In the Oakland case, a tribe got a friendly lawmaker to insert language into a federal spending bill designating special federal trust land.
McCain said after the hearing that he was still deciding whether to introduce legislation to further restrict off-reservation gambling. "I think that there is a problem," he said.
In the House, Resources Committee Chairman Richard Pombo, R-Calif., has circulated draft legislation that would restrict off-reservation casinos to "Indian Economic Opportunity Zones" where numerous tribes could build casinos in one area.
McCain heard different perspectives from tribal leaders at Tuesday's hearing.
James W. Ransom, chief of New York's St. Regis Mohawk Tribe, which is trying for a Catskills casino, said tribes should be allowed to build off-reservation.
"What if it's in a tribe's and a state's mutual interest to pursue off-reservation gaming?" he asked.
But Deron Marquez, chairman of the San Manuel Band of Mission Indians, which operates a profitable casino in Southern California, said he opposed the trend. Marquez's tribe faces potential competition from several other tribes that want to locate nearby.
"If these are allowed to go through, as I said in my testimony, this will be the end of what we know as tribal government gaming," Marquez said.
Tribal leaders also came under fire at the hearing for refusing to reveal their revenues. There is no requirement for tribes to open their books to the non-tribal public, and most of them don't.
"Every other form of government in this country, county, state, municipal and federal government publishes their numbers," Sen. Tom Coburn, R-Okla., told tribal leaders. "Transparency and sunshine is great for you in the long run."
Other news from around the same time
Baptists to help track down illegal machines - Sunday 12th of June 2005
South Carolina's largest religious group has volunteered to help police find illegal gambling ....
Japan could be next Asian hotbed for legalized gaming - Sunday 12th of June 2005
Where will be the next casino hotspot in Asia after Macau and Singapore?An expert from Osaka Univers....
Top banks to arrange two casino bond sales - Sunday 12th of June 2005
Two Macau casino outfits have picked bankers to arrange more than half a billion US dollars (HK$3.9 ....
Citizens want inquiry on VLT addictions - Sunday 12th of June 2005
Families of video-lottery-terminal addicts are calling for a national inquiry into the social impact....
PartyGaming surges after biggest UK float in 5 yrs - Sunday 12th of June 2005
Shares in online casino group PartyGaming surged on Monday after it completed the biggest Lond....
Numbers indicate big payoff for Falls, Ont. casinos - Sunday 12th of June 2005
The Ontario Lottery and Gaming Corp.'s $1 billion gamble on building a second casino in Niagara Fall....
WEB POKER CHIPS ARE DOWN - Sunday 12th of June 2005
Poker firm PartyGaming has been valued at well over £4.6bn in the biggest flotation in London since....
Giant Macau casino wins convention boost from China: report - Sunday 12th of June 2005
China has snubbed Hong Kong and other established Chinese expo venues to stage one of its most prest....
Coral Eurobet heads league - Sunday 12th of June 2005
BRITAIN’S appetite for a flutter has transformed Coral Eurobet into the country’s biggest privat....
Innocent fun or high-risk thrill? - Sunday 12th of June 2005
The big-hitting gamblers in the City of London might be licking their lips at the most intriguing sh....